From Mastro to PSA to Heritage: The Journey of a Signed 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle

I noticed a nice signed, raw, 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card while perusing Mastro’s September 2000 catalog and wondered if it ever got graded. Yup! Heritage sold it for $132k in August 2021.

Here’s how Mastro described the card back in 2000:

The prized possession of any Topps baseball card collection is the 1952 Mickey Mantle rookie card. In prime condition, its cost is dear for the collector who seeks the highest grades possible. However, in the real world, most such cards passed through young hands for years, with the resultant wear that is necessary in creating the value for the very scarce high condition examples. This 1952 Topps Mantle, with rounded corners and creases, is an example of a card that LOOKS like a vintage card almost 50 years old. With that said, the card does have good color and an unmarred image of Mantle. In addition, the great Yankee slugger has graced the card with an ink signature which grades 8.5/9. The most sought afterTopps card, signed by Mickey Mantle, a perfect combination. LOA.

Here’s a nicer photo of the front and back of the card slabbed, as scanned by Heritage.

This is their description of the card:

The Mick leaves his mark…

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle Signed #311 PSA Poor 1, Auto 8. If a mathematician were to undertake the task of calculating the probability of this card’s existence in the collecting hobby today, beginning with Mickey Mantle’s unsteady debut in pinstripes, we would see this relic for the lightning-strike-on-a-lottery-winner that it is. Though the Mick now stands near the pinnacle of the baseball pantheon, he might just as easily have fallen into anonymity had he not heeded his father’s advice to soldier on after early failures in Joe DiMaggio’s shadow.

Mantle’s early departure from the Majors alone might have deleted his number 311 card from the Topps company’s late season printing run of the rare and coveted high number series, and surely would have left little interest in having one autographed by a Yankee drop-out if its production continued. But, as it stands, this most famous baseball card of the post-war era remains painfully scarce despite the elite status of its subject. Planning miscues for the fledgling Topps company delayed the release of the final 1952 baseball series until far too late in the season, the packs made available to only a small fragment of American geography, and for a very limited time. Hundreds of cases were left to languish in a warehouse until the need for storage space was solved by a burial at sea of the obsolete stock.

This brings us to the final twist of fate. Today, there’s not a living legend who hasn’t autographed hundreds if not thousands of rookie cards. As a collecting subgenre, signed trading cards has never been more popular. But this hobby advancement was in its infancy when the Mick succumbed to liver failure in 1995. Only fourteen signed examples of this card appear in the PSA population.

Oddly, that population lists only the grade of the card itself, and not that of the autograph, and this is one of three listed at a Poor 1 assessment. Six are simply “Authentic.” While the significant edge and corner wear validate the grade, the image area is a beauty, far better than the technical rating. The autograph itself is applied in 8/10 blue ballpoint vertically, which proves to be the ideal position, making use of the largest area of blank space the obverse of this important relic affords. A wonderful autographed example of the hobby’s post-war trading card king. Encapsulated by PSA, Poor 1 Auto 8.

Today, there are 20 signed 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle cards in PSA’s signed Pop Report.

Happy Collecting!

1952 Topps Baseball – A Hobby Game-Changer

I can never get enough of 1952 Topps, so when I stumbled on Ted Taylor’s “Milestones” article from the September ’87 Baseball Cards Magazine, I knew I had to share it. Classic read!

I wish I could still get a high-quality set for $23,000, like in 1987! Also, the author mentioned picking up 1952 Topps cello packs the following summer in ’53; I’ve heard about this before and will dig deeper, maybe for a future Unopened Market Report Newsletter. Anywho, here’s the entire piece.

Happy collecting!

10 Original Mickey Mantle Photos Used For His Early Bowman, Topps, and Wheaties Baseball Cards

Vintage baseball cards are incredibly popular, but people sometimes forget that baseball card manufacturers had to find original photographs to design the cards around. Here are some original photos of Mickey Mantle that Bowman, Topps, and Wheaties used on some of his earlier baseball cards.

1951 Bowman #253 and 1953 Topps #82 Mickey Mantle Cards

1951 Bowman and 1953 Topps Mickey Mantle Original Photograph
1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle
1953 Topps #82 Mickey Mantle

1951 Wheaties Mickey Mantle

1951 Wheaties Mickey Mantle Original Photograph
1951 Wheaties #G Mickey Mantle

1952 Bowman #101 Mickey Mantle

1952 Bowman Mickey Mantle Original Photograph
1952 Bowman #101 Mickey Mantle

1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle Original Photograph
1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle

1954 Bowman #65 Mickey Mantle

1954 Bowman Mickey Mantle Original Photograph
1954 Bowman #65 Mickey Mantle

1956 Topps #135 Mickey Mantle

1956 Topps Mickey Mantle Original Photograph – Headshot
1956 Topps Mickey Mantle Original Photograph – Action Shot
1956 Topps #135 Mickey Mantle

1958 Topps #487 Mickey Mantle All-Star

1958 Topps Mickey Mantle All-Star Original Photograph
1958 Topps #487 Mickey Mantle All-Star

1958 Topps World Series Batting Foes Mickey Mantle and Hank Aaron

1958 Topps World Series Batting Foes Original Photograph
1958 Topps #418 Mickey Mantle / Hank Aaron World Series Batting Foes

1960 Topps Rival All-Stars Mantle & Boyer

1960 Topps Rival All-Stars Mantle & Boyer Original Photograph

The photo of Mantle and Boyer was taken in 1957, three years before Topps released the popular 1960 Topps Rival All-Stars card.

1960 Topps #160 RIval All-Stars Mantle & Boyer

Happy collecting!

PS: I put this blog post together ~ three years ago and am republishing it. None of these photos are of items in my collection, and I don’t have good records of the auctions/collections I pulled them from.

The PSA 8 Graded 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle Sotheby’s Auctioned In 2005

In June 2005, Sotheby’s offered this gorgeous PSA 8 graded 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle in their Important Sports Memorabilia and Cards catalog. The expected sales price was $40-50k! It’s now a million-dollar card after changing hands at least two more times!

I’m unsure what Sotheby’s sold the card for, or if it changed hands again, but in November 2014, it showed up in SCP’s Fall Premier Auction, where it sold for $268k.

Then, in May 2017, Memory Lane had the same card in their Spring Holy Grail Rarities Auction, where it sold for $462k.

I’m unsure if that buyer sold it since, but the PSA Card page for the cert shows that it was re-slabbed. Behold, over a million dollars in its plastic tomb!

It would be pretty cool if someone would trace the lineage of all the high-grade (PSA and SGC 8+) 1952 Mickey Mantle cards. It’s sort of just happened that I’ve started such a task with the T206 Wagner cards:

Happy Collecting!

A Look Back at the 1952 Topps Partial Uncut Sheet Auctioned at the 1992 National

Superior Galleries auctioned off this awesome 1952 Topps partial uncut sheet of 12 triple-printed cards via the 13th National Sports Collectors Convention Auction in July 1992. I’d love to find a copy in color!

First, here’s the sheet’s complete description:

1952 Topps Partial Uncut Sheet of 12 Cards. This unique sheet has a triple-printed image on each card. Extremely difficult uncut sheet to acquire. Contains the following triple-printed cards: Johnny Mize, Jackie Jenson. This sheet must be seen to be appreciated. A great item for you uncut sheet collectors. Overall Excellent condition with some creases and some partial cards. Estimated Value $1200-2000.

There are a few of these in the hobby; in November 2013, Heritage sold this 9-card example for $1,673 (the back was also multi-printed).

Then, a few years later, in August 2015, they sold these multi-printed panels for $334 (which today feels like a robbery by the buyer!)

And in the spring of 2020, REA sold this double print error uncut panel for $1,680.

How many of these came from the same printing? I have no idea! But to learn more about 1952 Topps uncut sheets, I highly recommend the article What In The Wide World Of Sports Is Going On Here? by The Topps Archives.

Also, check out The Uncut Sheet Archive for more items like these, and happy collecting!

The Top 25 Most Expensive Baseball Cards In 1993

“For those with cash, here are the top 25 most expensive baseball cards,”…as reported in the October 1993 issue of Sports Cards Magazine.

What really stands out is that there wasn’t a single contemporary or modern card on the list (“Sorry, there are no Frank Thomas or Ken Griffey rookie cards on this list”). However, the author also pointed out there wasn’t even a Ted Williams or a Joe DiMaggio (despite their popularity in the hobby at the time). The “youngest” card was a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle (though only 41 years old at the time), which is like including a card from 1983 on a list today.

1952 Topps Baseball Type Photos and Crossovers

The 1952 Topps Baseball set is the crown jewel of post-war cards. Driven by my passion for uncovering the original photos behind iconic cards, I’m building the ultimate resource for the photos used in this legendary set. And since many of these images appeared across other sets of the era, I’m including those crossovers too.

If you have any additions, please reach out to me via e-mail or on X.