The early 1990s have a nostalgic place in my collecting soul since I stopped collecting cards somewhere around 1997 before returning to the hobby as an adult. Today, my collecting and hobby interest is focused more on post-war vintage vs. this late “junk” era, but there are some important cards from this time. Some stand out to me today because I remember their popularity at the time, others because of today’s market prices, and others just because of the player’s career performance. No matter the reason, here are 18 early 1990s baseball cards that came to my mind that you might be interested in adding to your collection.
1990 Leaf #300 Frank Thomas
At its release, all the kids in my neighborhood wanted to get these Leaf cards, which we treated as a premium release at the time. I think I focus on the Frank Thomas card from this set today because our family had moved to Chicago, and he became the decade’s premier player.
1990 Score #697 Bo Jackson
Bo Jackson’s accolades across multiple sports led him to be considered one of the best athletes of all time. He was incredibly popular in the hobby, and this photo is simply iconic.
1990 Topps #414 Frank Thomas
I think I focus on this card more as an adult because of what I said earlier about Frank’s performance on the field, and as a hobby historian today, the story of the No Name on Front card brings a lot of attention to 1990 Topps as a set.
1990 Topps #414 Frank Thomas No Name on Front
The No Name on Front 1990 Topps Frank Thomas card is a bucket list card for a ton of collectors.
1990 Topps #USA1 George Bush
We now believe there are two versions of this card: glossy-coated cards that Topps gave to President Bush and ones without the coating that Topps probably didn’t intend for public release. Cards were peaking at this time, so the card got a lot of attention, and it still demands incredible prices today.
1991 Topps #333 Chipper Jones
Chipper didn’t play much until 1995, so I think my inclusion of this card is based on the popularity of the 1991 Chipper Jones cards today and my memories of watching every Braves game on TV.
1991 Upper Deck #SP1 Michael Jordan
I mean…yeah, of course.
1991 Upper Deck #SP2 Ryan/Henderson
Upper Deck did a great job making exciting cards, and this Nolan Ryan and Rickey Henderson card captured a fantastic day in baseball history.
1992 Bowman #302 Mariano Rivera
1992 Bowman was super popular when it was released, but the Rivera card being on this list is more a result of his career accolades than my younger collecting journeys.
1992 Donruss Elite Cal Ripken Jr.
I’ve written a lot about Cal Ripken Jr. in the past; add this one to the bucket list.
1992 Fleer #712 Frank Thomas
If you collected cards during the junk era, you absolutely knew about this card.
1992 Fleer Update #U-92 Mike Piazza
I’ve included the Fleer Update Piazza rookie card on this list due to its popularity today, which is in a tight race with his 1992 Bowman card. But I think, as kids, we all preferred his 1992 Topps Stadium Club card.
1992 Upper Deck #SP3 Deion Sanders
Another multi-sport superstar, Deion Sanders was a high performer on two fields and has continued to be relevant in sports as a commentator, public figure, and coach. Upper Deck did a great job on this 1992 Upper Deck card, blending football and baseball together.
1993 SP #279 Derek Jeter
Today, this is Jeter’s most desirable rookie card, and high-grade variants dwarf most sales of cards from this era.
1993 Topps #98 Derek Jeter
Derek Jeter is one of the most popular baseball players of all time, and Topps is the most celebrated brand, so I feel like this card has to be included on any list of great 1990s baseball cards, though I prefer his Pinnacle rookie card.
1994 SP #15 Alex Rodriguez Foil Die-Cut
Alex Rodriguez was a monster when he came into the majors, and this card was a beast when it first came on the market and was a quick addition to many top 100 baseball cards of all-time lists.
1994 Upper Deck Mantle/Griffey Jr. Autograph
In the days before there were more inserts and specialty cards in sets than base cards, any insert/chase was popular. I think this card may be underrated (despite high prices) when you couple Mantle and Griffey with the way cards were made and printed in the first half of the 1990s.
1995 Pinnacle #128 Ken Griffey Jr.
Who didn’t laugh and get a kick out of the Griffey bubble gum bubble card?
Are there any key early 1990s baseball cards that stand out to you that I may have missed? Let me know in the comments; happy collecting!
Subscribe to The Post War Cards Newsletter!